This book changed how I see leadership and growth in my daily work.
Good to Great: Reader Reviews & Ratings
Loading…
Write a Review
Your Review
0/500
Other reviews
29 total
Miller's Hardware story shows how good companies get stuck and fail to grow without change.
Good ideas but the study feels a bit dry. Still, the Level 5 leadership concept is useful for small teams.
The Miller's Hardware example of settling for good enough really stuck with me. I thought about how many local businesses I know are just happy to survive instead of pushing for excellence like Trailhead Outfitters did. It's easy to be comfortable with steady profits and loyal regulars, but the book makes it clear that complacency eventually eats away at growth. Collins shows that without making the leap to true excellence, you stay stuck on a plateau while competitors who choose to strive for greatness steal your customers. The detail about Miller's not updating their camping inventory since 2020 while Trailhead specialized in high-quality gear was a powerful illustration of how stagnation leads to losing key segments. It made me realize that being profitable and having happy customers isn't the same as being great, and that the gap between good and great is often just a choice to stop being comfortable and start pursuing something extraordinary instead.
The idea that you must hire the right people before deciding what the business should do was a surprising insight.
The story of Miller's Hardware shows how staying comfortable with steady profits and not updating inventory or training staff to match competitors like Trailhead Outfitters keeps a business stuck on the good enough plateau instead of achieving excellence through Level 5 Leadership, First Who Then What, and the Flywheel Effect. Collins proves that small consistent actions like hiring passionate specialists, making tough long-term decisions to invest in high-quality gear, and pushing the flywheel with aligned weekly steps can turn a solid local store into an extraordinary leader that outperforms competitors who rely on charm or quick fixes rather than humility, team alignment, and an unwavering focus on their hedgehog concept of being the best at their core business.
The Miller's Hardware example really stuck with me. I see how many of us settle for good enough when we could push for excellence instead.
Reading about the Stockdale Paradox made me realize that balancing brutal facts with unshakable faith is harder than it sounds and essential for avoiding the doom loop that traps many companies in stagnation.
Collins' Level 5 Leadership concept changed how I see my own management style. I used to think being charismatic was key, but the book shows that quiet humility paired with an unshakeable will to make tough, long-term decisions is actually what builds sustainable success. For example, the story of Darwin Smith at Kimberly-Clark illustrates this perfectly. He sold off the profitable paper mills to invest in consumer goods like Kleenex, even when Wall Street mocked him as reckless. Instead of taking credit, he looked out the window and credited his team when things went right. This Window and Mirror mindset builds trust because employees feel valued when leaders take responsibility for failures instead of blaming others. It's not about being a nice boss; it's about having the resolve to prioritize the organization's future over personal glory or short-term stock spikes. This approach creates a culture where people feel safe to take risks and innovate, which is essential for breaking through the good enough plateau. While some might find the idea of extreme humility counterintuitive, the research proves that leaders who shun the spotlight and build organizations that thrive long after they're gone are the ones who truly transform companies from good to great.
Good to Great.
This book changed my perspective on leadership by showing how humility paired with resolve creates sustainable success.
Good to Great is just okay for me.
Miller's story made me realize that being 'good enough' is actually a trap that stops companies from reaching their true potential.
Miller's Hardware story really showed me why settling for good enough keeps businesses stuck.
This book changed how I see my own career path.
Miller's Hardware example shows how 'good enough' kills growth when leaders stop pushing for excellence.
This book clearly shows how Level 5 Leadership helps companies break the good enough plateau.
The Flywheel Effect analogy helped me understand how consistent small actions eventually create unstoppable momentum that drives real transformation.
This book changed how I see my own business potential.
The idea that you must hire the right people first before defining strategy is a powerful lesson I will apply immediately.